duami
Score by pillar
reliability: LOW (T1 single-shot, not credited - requires T3 >=24h)
Context-cost
tools/listPaid on every request. With 61 tools (>p95), a tool-sprawl signal that degrades tool selection.
MCP primitive coverage
the quality score covers toolsWhy this score — causal attribution
Each penalty: measure → mechanism → effect → Δscore.
61 outils (≥p95) → too many tools saturate the agent's tool-selection space → ↑ taux d'appel au mauvais outil
~18k tokens (≥p95) → tool defs are paid on EVERY request → exhausts the window + ongoing cost
[MCP06] lethal trifecta: untrusted-content ingestion + sensitive-data access + exfil/destruction -> an injection can exfiltrate → MCP security flaw → tool: (serveur)
0 declared annotations → destructiveHint/openWorldHint missing -> worst-case defaults → the tool is treated as destructive & open-world by clients
65% typed+described params → schema = the contract the agent fills in → more malformed calls
4 clusters consolidables → list/get/search/... repeated on the same object → candidates to merge into composite tools
proto 2024-11-05 (4 rev. behind 2025-11-25) → outdated protocol version → recent features unavailable, recent clients weakened
no OAuth discovery (.well-known missing) → RFC 9728/8414 not exposed → auth not auto-discoverable by clients
Security — OWASP MCP Top 10
Combines untrusted-content ingestion (1), sensitive-data access (61) and exfiltration/destruction (7). A prompt-injection could read a secret then exfiltrate it.
Fix: scinder en 2 serveurs : un MCP « lecture/contenu non-fiable » (read-only, openWorldHint) isolé du MCP « privilégié » (données sensibles + exfil/destruction).
(serveur)Suggested composite optimizations
agent (outil unique avec param `action`, ou sous-serveur namespacé)intent (outil unique avec param `action`, ou sous-serveur namespacé)group (outil unique avec param `action`, ou sous-serveur namespacé)bid (outil unique avec param `action`, ou sous-serveur namespacé)renommer pour distinguerBadge — paste it in your README
[](https://checkmcp.dev/report?url=https%3A%2F%2Fduami.ai%2Fmcp)